QUOTE(Rodzilla @ Mar 19 2008, 03:10 PM) [snapback]466780[/snapback]
I may just be a scaredy-cat (I'm the same guy who avoids kaempferol and arecoline) but I sent you a PM
got it. I did some research. Apparently he is ignoring the different isoflavons. You can't group ALL icariin derivatives together. As seen here:
QUOTE
Phytochemistry. 2007 May;68(10):1448-58. Epub 2007 Apr 16. Links
Taxonomic, genetic, chemical and estrogenic characteristics of Epimedium species.Shen P, Guo BL, Gong Y, Hong DY, Hong Y, Yong EL.
Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, National University Hospital, Yong Loo Lin School of Medicine, Lower Kent Ridge Road, Singapore 119074, Republic of Singapore.
To understand the factors contributing to estrogenic properties of extracts from the genus Epimedium L. (Berberidaceae), we performed taxonomic, genetic and chemical characterization on 37 specimens from 18 species and related these to estrogen receptor (ERalpha and ERbeta) bioactivity, as measured by reporter genes in stable human cells. Boot strap values derived from amplified fragment length polymorphisms indicated that specimens of E. koreanum, E. brevicornum, E. myrianthum, E. leishanense, and E. membranaceum were genetically distinct and this was supported by their very similar ERalpha activities. In contrast, specimens from E. pubescens and E. sagittatum were diverse both genetically, chemically and in terms of ERalpha and ERbeta bioactivities. Strikingly, a genetic cluster comprising six rare Epimedium species exhibited strongest ERalpha and ERbeta activity, and this bioactivity was positively correlated with content of trace flavonoid aglycones (kaempferol, apigenin, quercetin, luteolin and breviflavone

.
In contrast, there was no association between estrogenic activity and the major flavonol glycoside constituents (icariin and epimedin A-C). Although they exhibited equally strong ERalpha and ERbeta activity, E. koreanum can be clearly differentiated from E. pubescens and E. brevicornum by genetic distance and its significantly lower content of epimedin C. Our morphologic, genetic, chemical and bioactivity profiling provide the basis for the production of extracts with reproducible estrogenic properties. Such reproducibility will be critical for the standardization of Epimedium-based products.
PMID: 17434191 [PubMed - indexed for MEDLINE]
and again here
QUOTE
Zhejiang Da Xue Xue Bao Yi Xue Ban. 2005 Mar;34(2):131-6.Links
[Preparation of two derivatives from icariin and investigation of their estrogen-like effects.][Article in Chinese]
Ye HY, Liu J, Lou YJ.
College of Pharmaceutical Sciences, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou 310031, China.
OBJECTIVE: To investigate the estrogen-like activities of icariin (ICA), icaritin (ICT) and desmethylicaritin (DICT) and their structure/activity relationships. METHODS: ICT was hydrolyzed from ICA by cellulase and then DICT was demethylated from ICT in boron tribromide and dichloromethane system. Estrogen-sensitive MCF-7 cells and T47D cells were co-incubated with different concentrations of test compounds for 6 and 9 d respectively, and the cell proliferation was measured by MTT. RESULTS: ICT and DICT both markedly enhanced cell proliferation. Compared with estradiol (10.(-9) mol/L), the proliferative effects of 10.-6 mol/L ICT and DICT on MCF-7 cells were 90.0% and 94.0% (P<0.01), respectively, and those of T47D cells were 65.6% and 50.0%. (P<0.01). But this phenomenon was not observed with ICA. Cell proliferation induced by ICT and DICT was completely antagonized by 10.(-7 )mol/L pure estrogen receptor antagonist, ICI182,780. CONCLUSION: ICT and DICT possess estrogen-like activity of enhancing proliferation in MCF-7 and T47D cells. However, ICA appears to have no estrogenicity on MCF-7 and T47D cell lines in vitro.
PMID: 15812886 [PubMed - indexed for MEDLINE]
I would however, not close the book on this as of yet... one comment in this study makes me wonder for a second..
QUOTE
Pharmazie. 2005 Feb;60(2):120-5.Links
Determination of rat urinary metabolites of icariin in vivo and estrogenic activities of its metabolites on MCF-7 cells.Liu J, Ye H, Lou Y.
Department of Pharmacology and Toxicology, College of Pharmaceutical Sciences, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou, PR China.
To confirm that the estrogenic activity of icariin is based on the close relationship between the structures of its metabolites and the effects of their binding to target hormone receptors, the metabolism of icariin in rat urine was analyzed in vivo, and the estrogenic activity of its metabolites was measured in cultured MCF-7 human breast cancer cells, respectively. By CZE analysis, peaks corresponding to the relative positions of desmethylicaritin and icaritin were observed in the urine sample. Structural analysis following LC-ESI-MS revealed molecular ions [M-H]- of 512.8, 353.3, and 367.0 for metabolites consistent with those of icariside II, desmethylicaritin, and icaritin. Icariin, icaritin, and desmethylicaritin were analyzed for their estrogenicity using MCF7-cell proliferation (E-screen test). MCF-7 cells were cultured in an estradiol free medium and then exposed to 10(-8) to 10(-5) mol/L icariin and its metabolites, icaritin and desmethylicaritin, for 6 days. Icaritin and desmethylicaritin significantly increased cell proliferation, and the cell number increased from 1.61 to 4.14 fold compared with the untreated control, but the parent compound icariin failed to exhibit this effect. These results indicate that icariin is converted to icariside II, desmethylicaritin, and icaritin in vivo, and that the latter two act as a weak xenoestrogen on MCF-7 cells.
PMID: 15739900 [PubMed - indexed for MEDLINE]
Is this saying that even if you are taking icariin it metabolizes into the lesser more estrogenic forms of itself?